Heated Gemstones vs Unheated Gemstones

Tell a friend:

What is heated gemstones?

Heat treatment is a common treatment process used for to lighten, darken or even change the color of gemstones. Heating can also improve the clarity of some gemstones.

Out of all gemstone treatments, heating is one of the most widely accepted. Some people view it as an extension of the gemstone’s formation, as the heat could have been applied by the earth before they are mined. And usually the change because of heat treatment is permanent.

One of the most commonly (and routinely) heated gemstones is corundum, which includes ruby and sapphire. Unless it’s stated otherwise, you should assume the ruby or sapphire you are buying is heated.

Other gemstones like citrine, tanzanite and aquamarine are also commonly heated. I’ll let you know the effects of heating them later in this article.

Does heated gemstone mean it’s not real?

Not at all, heating gemstones have nothing to do with whether the gem is genuine or not. Many consider the treatment as an extension of the natural process.

As long as the seller is transparent, and the color by heating is permanent (which it usually is), heat treatment is widely accepted in the gemstone industry. And it doesn’t mean the heated gemstone is lower in quality or less authentic.

How to identify if the gemstone is heated? Is it detectable?

Although it’s not difficult to look for signs of a gemstone that has been heated, a lot of the time it’s impossible to know that it has NOT been.

The signs of heating usually appear only when the gem is heated to a high temperature like for ruby and sapphire. Their heat treatment is usually detectable.

Ruby and sapphire can withstand high temperature. They are often heated to higher than 1000°c. Sometimes even reaching 2000°c. However, the inclusions in them, which are other minerals, sometimes melt or explode under such high temperature. And that will be evidence that the stone has been heated.

For many semi precious gemstones, it’s almost impossible to know whether it is heated. This is because the temperature of heat treatment is low and could have happened in nature. So the lab couldn’t conclude whether the result is by nature or by heat that’s applied afterwards.

Corundum mineral rough crystal

Does heating a gemstone lower its value?

For lower-priced gemstones, the price between heated or unheated won’t differ too much generally. For example, a carnelian that is heated for its fiery orange color won’t have a much higher price tag than an untreated one.

However, for high quality and higher priced gems, like ruby and sapphire, that are unheated and come with a lab report that states there is no evidence of heating, the price will be higher. The rarer the gemstone, the more premium can be charged for the unheated version. For example, a large high quality ruby with little to no inclusion is extremely rare, if it’s untreated, the price can be 3-5 times higher than the heated ones.

For cases like blue topaz and tanzanite, heating will increase the value of the gemstone as the original color is not desirable for most buyers.

What are the commonly heated gemstones?

The following gemstones are routinely heated. Unless there is a lab report stating it’s not, you should assume heat treatment has been applied.

Ruby

Heating ruby can take away the purple hue and produce a pure red color.

Rubies with very small rutile inclusions (silk) can be heated to a high temperature and cooled quickly to produce a clearer stone.

Sapphire

Heating some sapphires to a high temperature in an oxygen-free environment will deepen its blue color, while heating it in air can lighten it.

Sapphires with very small rutile inclusions (silk) can be heated to a high temperature and cooled quickly to produce a clearer stone.

Pale yellow sapphire can be heated to produce golden yellow sapphire.

Aquamarine

Aquamarine is routinely heated to take away the green and yellow tints. The result is the pure blue color aquamarine that people love.

One thing to note is that heating will not make the stone more saturated, but only take away the green and yellow undertones.

Amethyst

Amethyst can be heated to lighten or darken its color to achieve an attractive vibrant purple.

Some types of amethyst can be heated to turn yellow, which some dishonest sellers sell it as the more expensive citrine.

Some amethysts can even be heated to turn green, which is called prasiolite. Virtually all prasiolite comes from heat treated amethyst.

Citrine

Almost all heat treated citrine has a reddish hue.

Natural citrine can be heated to deepen its color from pale yellow to a desirable orange yellow.

A lot of the ‘citrine’ in the market comes from heating amethyst. They usually have a burnt orange to brown color.

Topaz

Heating some yellow topaz can give a pink topaz.

In combination of heating and radiation, colorless topaz can turn blue. A deep blue color is called “London blue”, a medium one is known as “Swiss blue” and a light one is called “sky blue”.

Tourmaline

Heating dark green tourmaline can lighten its color to an emerald green, which has a much higher value in the market. And dark brown color tourmaline (dravite) can be heated to a lighter color. Most heat treatments can’t be detected.

Tanzanite

Almost all tanzanites in the market are heat treated to achieve the vibrant blue color with a violet hue. Natural tanzanite with deep blue color exists but it’s very rare.

This article from Lapigems demonstrates the effect of tanzanite heating.

Zircon

Some brown zircons can change to a desirable blue zircon by heating it in an oxygen free environment.

And it can also change to golden, red or colorless if it’s heated in air.

Kunzite

Sometimes kunzite is irradiated and heated to pale color stone into pinkish-purple color.

Morganite

Morganite, like aquamarine which is in the same mineral family, is heated to achieve a more popular color. The orange colored stones are heated to a pink morganite. This heat treatment is not detectable, but a morganite with an orange tint is more likely to be unheated.

Amber

Heating can deepen color and produce ‘sun spangles’ inside amber.

Tiger's Eye

Yellow tiger’s eye turns red when heated. Almost all red tiger’s eye in the market is heat treated. Red tiger’s eye is not more expensive than the yellow one.

Carnelian

Carnelian can change from a brown-yellow to an orange-red with heating, though natural carnelian with good color is not very rare.

Smoky Quartz

Very dark smoky quartz can be heated to lighten the color. And some smoky quartz can turn yellow after heating and be sold as citrine.

The benefits of heating gemstones

As you can see from the commonly heated gemstones from above, heat treatment can improve a stone’s color to a more desirable one (according to market’s demand). And sometimes it changes the color so dramatically that the heated stone is given a new name, like in the case of tanzanite.

The drawbacks of heating gemstones

Heat treatment with a lower temperature doesn’t have any drawbacks most of the time. However, with high temperature like the case for ruby and sapphire, the gem may become “slightly more brittle than usual, and care must be taken not to damage pointed faceted corners and edges” according to this GIA article.

Also, some other mineral inclusions inside the gem may expand more than the host gem. This causes cracks which may lower the value and durability.

Heat treating a stone can improve its color and clarity. More times than not, the treatment is not detectable. So now if a seller tells you the aquamarine that they sell is unheated, you should take it with a grain of salt.

At Unearthed Gemstones, although we don’t claim whether the gem has been heated, we do make sure all the gemstones are genuine. Click here to check out the selection.

If you found out something new after reading this, leave a comment! And click here to see our other articles.

References

  • Margaret W. Carruthers, Richard Efthim, and Ronald L. Bonewitz (2008). Rocks and Minerals – The Definitive Visual Guide. DK Publishing.
  • Renée Newman (2016). Gemstone Buying Guide. International Jewelry Publications
  • Antoinette Leonard Matlins (2010). Colored Gemstones The Antoinette Matlins Buying Guide. GemStone Press
  • Peter G. Read (2000). Gemmology. Taylor & Francis Ltd

Tell a friend:

1 thought on “Heated Gemstones vs Unheated Gemstones”

  1. I do agree with all of the ideas you’ve presented in your post. They are very convincing and will certainly work. Still, the posts are too short for novices. Could you please extend them a bit from next time? Thanks for the post.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *